Europe’s NATO Gamble: A Weakened Trump Could Become a Tougher Partner

Europe may be drawing the wrong conclusions from Donald Trump's domestic political difficulties. In an October 22 analysis, Modern Diplomacy argues that Republican setbacks in the November 3 US midterm elections would not necessarily moderate Washington's approach to NATO. Instead, a politically weakened president could intensify pressure on European allies, reduce American military commitments and pursue unilateral arrangements with Russia. The central warning is that Congress can restrict a formal US withdrawal from NATO, but cannot guarantee the credibility of American security commitments. European governments hoping that electoral pressure will restrain Trump may therefore be preparing for the wrong outcome.

The Pentagon is preparing difficult choices

The article identifies November 6 as a critical date, when Pentagon officials are expected to present Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth with options for America's military presence in Europe.

The review reflects Washington's determination to transfer primary responsibility for conventional European defence to European governments.

The analysis argues that the administration is also assessing allies according to their political cooperation with US foreign policy, particularly during the conflict with Iran.

This creates uncertainty not only about American troop numbers, but also about which European countries Washington will prioritise.

Congress can protect NATO's structure, not its credibility

American legislation restricts presidential authority to withdraw from NATO and imposes consultation requirements on major troop reductions.

But Modern Diplomacy distinguishes between preserving NATO's institutional framework and maintaining a credible American commitment to defend Europe.

Congress may prevent a formal withdrawal or constrain military reductions without controlling the president's statements, diplomatic decisions or willingness to respond during a crisis.

The article argues that this distinction matters for deterrence: Russia's assessment of American intentions depends heavily on presidential behaviour.

Europe risks retaining NATO's formal guarantees while becoming less confident about their practical meaning.

Washington is dividing European allies

The analysis highlights the Pentagon's reported preference for a smaller group of European partners, including Germany, Poland, the Netherlands and several Nordic countries.

Britain, France and the Baltic states are described as being outside this emerging arrangement.

According to the article, the division reflects disagreements over American policy towards Iran and Russia as well as assessments of military capability.

The concern is that selective cooperation could weaken solidarity within NATO, leaving some members uncertain about their position in Washington's strategic calculations.

Domestic pressure could produce foreign-policy concessions

Modern Diplomacy points to Trump's reported October agreement with Vladimir Putin over Russian diesel supplies as an example of domestic economic pressures influencing foreign policy.

The article argues that rising fuel prices and political dissatisfaction can encourage decisions intended to deliver immediate economic relief, even when they conflict with European preferences on Russia.

It also recalls Trump's decision to announce a withdrawal from Syria after the 2018 midterms.

These examples support the publication's interpretation that domestic political weakness does not necessarily translate into international restraint.

Republican dissent has limits

The article acknowledges that congressional resistance to Trump's foreign policy is growing, including criticism from Republican senators.

A Democratic-controlled House could strengthen oversight, influence defence appropriations and demand explanations for changes in American military deployments.

Nevertheless, the president would retain considerable authority over executive decisions and military policy.

The analysis therefore cautions against treating congressional opposition as a reliable safeguard against changes in Washington's European strategy.

Europe has a narrow legislative opportunity

Modern Diplomacy recommends concentrating European diplomatic efforts on the unfinished US defence legislation for 2027.

The proposed legislation could extend protections against reducing American troop numbers in Europe below 76,000 and impose additional scrutiny on Pentagon deployment decisions.

Such measures would not eliminate strategic uncertainty, but could slow the withdrawal of American capabilities and provide European governments with more time to strengthen their own forces.

The article identifies the final legislation expected in December as an important indicator of how much institutional protection Congress is prepared to provide.

Three possible outcomes, one underlying problem

The publication outlines three scenarios following the midterms.

Its central scenario envisages continued American pressure on NATO, accompanied by selective troop reductions and more differentiated treatment of allies.

A more disruptive scenario involves accelerated military withdrawals and disputes over congressional restrictions.

A less confrontational outcome would preserve existing deployment protections and temporarily stabilise transatlantic relations.

These are the publication's scenarios, not established forecasts. All share the assumption that Washington's longer-term demand for greater European responsibility will continue.

The hard lesson: Congressional restraints cannot replace credible American commitments

Modern Diplomacy's central argument is that Europe should distinguish between Trump's domestic political vulnerability and his continuing authority over foreign and security policy.

The publication recommends engaging Congress to preserve American military commitments while accelerating European rearmament.

Even stronger legislative safeguards would provide only temporary reassurance if presidential support for NATO remained uncertain.

For European governments, the immediate challenge is to use whatever time American political institutions can provide to reduce their dependence on decisions made in Washington.